In softball and baseball, “eat it” means don’t throw the ball, and is used to let the fielder know there is no play. The term is often yelled out loud by surrounding players, those in the dugout, and coaches.
For example, if there is a runner on second base and the batter hits a slow chopper up the middle to the shortstop. The runner advances to third while the batter has a good chance of beating the throw from the the shortstop to first base. Thus, players and coaches might advise the shortstop to “eat it” because a throw would be too late, and might even allow the runner who went from second to third to advance home (and the batter to advance to second base).
So, while we all wish we were gold (or platinum) glove fielders, sometimes it’s just better to try and not make the play, and “eat it” helps communicate that fact in the moment.
Why Communication is Key
Baseball and softball are often likened to a game of chess. But instead of silent moves on a board, players vocally communicate their strategies and intentions through a rich lexicon of shouts and calls.
Beyond the common calls like “eat it” or “I got it,” there’s a symphony of communication that ensures seamless play.
“Mine!”
Ever watched a fly ball head towards the outfield and heard this assertive call? It’s to ensure fielders don’t collide or let a ball fall between them. Claiming the ball reduces confusion and potential injury.
“Back!”
A base runner’s constant vigil is to not get picked off. When they hear “back,” it’s the cue to dive or slide back to the base to avoid getting out.
“Down!” and “Up!”
These commands guide base runners during their journey around the bases. “Down” signals the need to slide, while “Up” tells the runner there’s no imminent threat, allowing them to stand and walk.
“Tag!”
It’s baseball, so it might seem like a “duh” but their are certain plays that go from a force out to a tag play in the blink of an eye. “Tag!” Informs the fielder to tag the runner instead of the base. It’s useful during run-downs or when the force out is not available.
“Talk” and Talk it Up!”
Speaking of communication, there are a couple of instances where players are instructed to “talk” or “talk it up.” In one instance, a coach might instruct the catcher to “talk” which means to go out and talk to the pitcher. The other “talk it up” might be instruction to the dugout to get louder and cheer on their teammates.
Read More: Dugout Storage & Organization Ideas
Understanding the vernacular of baseball and softball adds a layer of appreciation for the sports’ complexity. These aren’t just random shouts; they’re a coded language, developed over years, that players use to synchronize their actions, much like a well-conducted orchestra.
Why “Eat It?”
Back to the term at hand…why “eat it.” I mean, it’s not that much easier to say than “no throw.”
To start, the phrase “eat it” in the context of baseball and softball is idiomatic, meaning its origins and evolution might not directly correspond to the literal words used.
However, there are a few theories and similarities that might help explain its origin:
Idiomatic Expressions: Again, English is filled with idioms that don’t necessarily match their literal interpretations. To “eat one’s words,” for example, means to admit something was wrong after stating it. “Eat it” in baseball might similarly mean to “keep it” or “hold onto it” without the need for literal consumption.
Emphasis on Quick Decision: Just as “taking a bite out of something” implies a quick action, “eat it” might emphasize the need for a rapid decision on the field. Instead of deliberating, the player should instantly decide to hold onto the ball.
The Idea of Consumption: “Eating” something implies taking it in, absorbing it. In this sense, “eat it” might mean “keep the ball within yourself” or “absorb the play,” essentially preventing the ball from being thrown and potentially leading to an error.
A similar term is telling a player to “put it in their pocket.” Both phrases suggest not making a throw. It’s plausible that “eat it” is just another colorful way to convey the same idea, emphasizing the notion of keeping the ball close and not releasing it (plus, it’s easier to say).
Anyway, while it’s challenging to pinpoint the exact origin of “eat it” in the context of baseball and softball, it’s clear that the phrase has been widely accepted and understood in the sports community. Such idioms add character to the game, making it richer and more colorful for both players and fans!
“Eating it” isn’t just about avoiding a risky throw. It’s a nod to the complexity of baseball and softball, sports where mental acuity matches physical skill. Next time you’re watching a game, listen out for those shouts and appreciate the depth of strategy they represent.
